Defamation on Social Media in Indonesia and Online Review Risks

Posting an honest review has become an everyday habit. Consumers warn others about late deliveries, unresolved refunds and poor service. Yet a complaint can quickly become a dispute when the person named in it believes their reputation has been attacked.

Defamation on social media in Indonesia is not established simply because a review is negative. Since 2 January 2026, the assessment depends on the substance, context and target of the allegation under a different statute from the one most people still associate with online speech.

When Can a Negative Review Cross the Line into Defamation?

Article 433 of the National Criminal Code (“Law No. 1 of 2023”) defines defamation as attacking another person’s honour or reputation by alleging a particular matter, with the intention that it becomes publicly known. The Code’s elucidation excludes government bodies and groups, and the alleged act need not itself be a crime, so criticising a business differs from attacking an identifiable individual, such as a named owner or employee.

  •  A review stating that an order arrived two weeks late and that a promised refund was never paid describes a personal experience the reader can weigh.
  • A post declaring that a named owner is a fraudster makes a serious allegation of criminal conduct against a specific individual, and is far more likely to attract a complaint when no supporting records exist.

A negative review does not automatically amount to defamation, yet it is not shielded merely because its author believes it true. Article 433(3) provides that the conduct is not punishable where it is done in the public interest or out of necessary self-defence. A warning about a real risk to other consumers fits it more readily than a personal grievance.

How the ITE Law and the New Criminal Code Interact

Until 1 January 2026, online defamation was pursued mainly under Article 27A of the Electronic Information and Transactions (“ITE”) Law, introduced by Law No. 1 of 2024, with related provisions in Article 45(4) to (6). Article II of Law No. 1 of 2024 states that these provisions apply only until Law No. 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code takes effect. The Code took effect on 2 January 2026, so Article 27A should not be treated as the operative basis for conduct occurring after that date. For earlier conduct, Article 3 of the Code applies the new provision unless the earlier one is more favourable to the offender or an accomplice.

The Constitutional Court shaped the earlier regime in Decision No. 105/PUU-XXII/2024. It read “other person” in Article 27A as excluding government bodies, groups with specific identities, institutions, corporations, professions and positions, and protected constructive criticism on public matters. In Decision No. 12/PUU-XXIV/2026 (2 March 2026), the Court rejected a challenge to Article 433(1) and (3). It held that “a particular matter” in Article 433(1) means conduct that lowers a person’s honour or reputation, and that Article 433(3) protects expression made in the public interest or in necessary self-defence. This grants no general immunity to consumer reviews.

Under the Code, Article 433 separates spoken defamation from written defamation, with a heavier penalty for the latter, and a published post would ordinarily fall into the written category. Article 434 addresses fitnah, a false accusation, where the accused is given the chance to prove the allegation, fails to do so, and the allegation contradicts what the accused knew. Proof of truth is allowed only where the judge considers it necessary to assess a public interest or self-defence claim, or where an official is accused of conduct in office.

Article 440 makes defamation and fitnah under Articles 433 and 434 complaint based, so proceedings depend on a complaint from the victim. Article 441(1) is not a separate offence. It allows the penalty for Articles 433 to 439 to be increased by one third when an offence is committed through information technology, such as a social media post.

How to Publish a Critical Review Responsibly

The right to complain is real. Article 4(d) of the Consumer Protection Law (Law No. 8 of 1999) recognises a consumer’s right to have opinions and complaints heard about goods or services used. Articles 28E(3), 28F and 28J of the 1945 Constitution protect expression and access to information while requiring respect for others’ rights. These rights shape how a complaint is assessed but do not grant absolute immunity.

  • Describe what you personally experienced, including the date, transaction and product or service.
  • Separate verifiable facts from opinion, and present opinion as opinion.
  • Avoid accusing anyone of a crime, such as fraud, without solid grounds.
  • Leave out insults and unrelated personal details.
  • Keep receipts, messages, photographs and other records.
  • Use the seller’s complaint channel, a platform dispute process or consumer dispute settlement before going public.

None of this prevents consumers from speaking. A review should say what happened, support it where possible and stop short of accusations the author cannot substantiate. A grounded review lowers the risk without removing it, because the assessment turns on the full wording and context of the post.

Consumer writing an online review while referring to transaction records and customer service correspondence.

For strategic advice on employment structuring, regulatory compliance, or workforce risk management in Indonesia, please reach us at info@indvesto.com. We are ready to assist you with legal strategies designed to support and strengthen your business operations in Indonesia.

Email

info@indvesto.com

latest legal update

Other Legal Update